Abstract:
We reviewed the case notes and computed tomography scans of 22 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the vocal cord, in the period between 1992 and 1998. Interobserver concordance for all cases and accuracy and concordance between the methods for the operated patients were evaluated using the kappa test. Concordance was classified as follows: excellent for evaluating tumoral involvement of the thyroid and cricoid cartilages, extralaryngeal extension and lymph node staging; very good for tumoral involvement of vocal cords, posterior commissure and paraglottic space; good for tumoral involvement of the supraglottic and subglottic regions and tumoral staging; regular for tumoral involvement of the anterior commissure and arytenoid cartilage. The combination of clinical and computed tomography evaluation for T staging resulted in an accuracy and concordance with the pathological results of 89.47% and 84.9%, respectively, which were superior to isolated clinical or computed tomography analysis. The accuracy and pathological concordance of computed tomography for N staging was 100%, which was superior to clinical evaluation.
Resumo:
No período de 1992 a 1998, foram avaliados, retrospectivamente, exames de tomografia computadorizada e prontuários de 22 pacientes com carcinoma espinocelular de corda vocal. Avaliou-se a concordância entre observadores para todos os casos e a acurácia e concordância entre os métodos para os casos operados, utilizando-se o índice kappa. A concordância foi excelente para o comprometimento tumoral das cartilagens tireóide, cricóide, extensão extralaríngea e estadiamento linfonodal; ótima para o envolvimento tumoral das cordas vocais, comissura posterior e espaço paraglótico; boa para o envolvimento tumoral da supraglote, subglote e estadiamento tumoral; regular para o envolvimento tumoral da comissura anterior e cartilagem aritenóide. A utilização simultânea da avaliação clínica e tomográfica para o estadiamento T obteve acurácia e concordância com achados patológicos de 89,47% e 84,9%, respectivamente, sendo superior à análise clínica isolada ou tomográfica. A acurácia e concordância patológica da tomografia computadorizada para o estadiamento N foi de 100%, sendo superior à avaliação clínica.
|